Which

which 當主詞

當主詞(後面直接接動詞):

  • Which hero will save the day?(哪位英雄會拯救危機?)
    • Which hero 是主詞(執行動作的人)。
  • Which movie is playing tonight?(哪部電影今晚上映? → 電影是主詞)

which 當受詞

當受詞(助動詞後面接「人 + 一般動詞」):

  • Which hero do you like best?(你最喜歡哪位英雄?)
    • Which hero 是受詞(接收「喜歡」這個動作的對象)
  • Which movie did you watch?(你看了哪部電影? → 電影是受詞)

which 當 形容詞

which作為形容詞,修飾後面的名詞。
有作為分類的意思,那一個/什麼樣的/ 那一個種類

只要把你想問的「種類(名詞)」放在 Which 後面,就可以無限延伸

which + [種類]

  • Which cat is the fattest? (那一隻貓)
  • Which month is the hottest (那一個月份)
  • Which room is bigger, the living room or the kitchen?(那一間房間)
  • Which trip is the most exciting?(那一個短程旅行)
  • Which street are you looking for?(你在找哪一条街?)
  • Which house will you choose? 你会选择哪个房子?
  1. Which + 職業/人物
    • Which hero(哪位英雄)
    • Which teacher(哪位老師)
  2. Which + 東西/物品
    • Which car(哪輛車)
    • Which book(哪本書)
  3. Which + 時間/抽象概念
    • Which day(哪一天)
    • Which way(哪一條路 / 哪個方法)

Which 介系詞結尾

 Which + 名詞 ... [介系詞]
  • Which meeting room are you in
    • 原本是:You are in [which meeting room].(你在哪一間會議室裡面。)
    • 把疑問詞 Which meeting room 移到句首變成問句時,介系詞 in 就會自然而然地留在句尾。
  • What hotel are you staying at?(你住哪一家飯店?——at 也是留在句尾)

where 與 which 比較

Which meeting room(哪一間會議室)只是一個「名詞」,它本身沒有「in在裡面」的意思。

where 的組成其實就是 at/in/on + which place(在某個地方)。

  • ❌ Where are you in?
  • 在什麼地方的裡面,你在裡面?這在英文裡是錯的。

因此,當你想問「人在哪裡」時,直接用 where 當作介系詞的受詞即可:

  • Where are you?(你在哪裡?——不加 in)
  • Where are you staying?(你住在哪裡?——不需要在後面加 at)
  • Where are you going?(你要去哪裡?——不加 to,因為 where 已經包含方向了)

  • ❌ Which meeting room are you?(哪一間會議室你是?)
    • 人怎麼會變成一間會議室?
    • 必須明確表達:你是在哪一間會議室「裡面」。
  • 原本是:You are in [which meeting room].
    • 把 which meeting room 提到句首變成疑問句時,後面的介系詞 in 就被留下來了:
    • Which meeting room are you in?(你在哪一間會議室裡面?)

用 Which + 名詞(需要介系詞來交代位置或關係)

  • Which meeting room are you in?(你在哪一間會議室?)
  • Which team are you in?(你在哪一個團隊?)
  • Which hotel are you staying at?(你住在哪一家飯店?)

空間與位置情境(Location)

用來詢問人或物體確切在哪個房間、座位或實體空間內。

  • Which office are you in? (你在哪一間辦公室?)
  • Which seat are you sitting in? (你坐在哪一個座位上?)
  • Which building does he work in? (他在哪一棟大樓裡工作?)

組織、團隊與群體情境(Group / Organization)

用來詢問人被分配到哪一個部門、小組或班級。

  • Which team are you on? (你在哪一個團隊裡?——註:團體通常用介系詞 on)
  • Which department is she in? (她在哪一個部門?)
  • Which class are you in this semester? (你這學期在哪一個班級?)

生活與旅宿情境(Lifestyle / Travel)

用來詢問住在哪家飯店、搭乘哪班車、或看哪本書。

  • Which hotel are you staying at? (你住在哪一家飯店?)
  • Which platform is the train waiting at? (火車停在哪一個月台?)
  • Which page are we on? (我們翻到第幾頁了?)
  • Which drawer did you put the keys in? (你把鑰匙放在哪一個抽屜裡?)

results matching ""

    No results matching ""